Shooting film on the cheap – the impact on your style of photography

Let’s assume you’re new to film photography. For a small budget, let’s say $25.00 including shipping and handling, you can:

  • Buy a fixed focus, one time use or reusable camera,
  • Be brave and buy an old compact autofocus motorized camera,
  • Be bold and buy an old SLR, manual or autofocus – your choice,

But it will have an impact on the photos you’re taking. The type of camera you pick will force you to a certain style of images. Very simple cameras (like one-time-use point and shoot) are so limited in their performance envelope, and give you so little latitude in terms of settings, that you will be forced to devote all your attention to the only three things you can really control: the choice of the film, the composition of the image, and using (or not using) the electronic flash.

On the other hand, pick a “semi-pro” autofocus SLR and a zoom (that you can get for the same price as a one-time-use point and shoot), and you will have such a large array of settings – shutter speed, aperture, focus point, metering patterns… that you could be overwhelmed, and lose interest in photography as a result.

If some art schools recommend that their students start learning photography with a one time use point and shoot, there’s a reason. The same reason why photographers with tens of thousands of dollars invested in high end equipment still like to return to very basic cameras from time to time.

The one-time-use cameras, and their close relatives – the “reusable” cameras are very simple – a fix focus lens, a fixed aperture, a single shutter speed, and generally an on/off switch to control the electronic flash. Their wide angle lens and the narrow fixed aperture guarantee that everything located between 4 ft and the infinity will be somehow in focus – you’ll have to keep your backgrounds simple so that your subject is not drawn into an overflow of information. With a shutter speed of 1/100 sec and no exposure metering system, those are fair weather cameras, counting on the exposure latitude of film – and on their electronic flash – to give you usable images.

CamerAgX reviews: the Five Below $7.00 reusable camera and Kodak Ektar H35

I wouldn’t shoot landscapes or photos of a large group of people with a reusable camera (not enough resolution), but for close-ups a camera like the Kodak Ektar H35 can deliver surprisingly interesting images.

The recommendation of the camera vendors is to keep the subject within 6 to 9ft of the lens, with the electronic flash on (even in bright daylight) and to pick a simple background. Ideally, composing your image in depth (foreground, middle ground, background) will help as well. That being said, creativity is about transgression – play your own partition.

Compact autofocus cameras are more adaptable than a typical one-time-use point and shoot: their metering and programmed exposure systems ensure that you get correctly exposed pictures in more situations, their autofocus that the subject is sharper, and the zoom gives you more ways to isolate a detail. But you still have no direct control over the aperture and the shutter speed, and only rarely over the electronic flash or the focus point.

Ile Rousse (Corsica). Canon Photura

CamerAgX reviews: Minolta AF-C, Canon Photura, Canon Photura 135, Argus M5600D

So, for all practical purposes, you have to work with them like slightly more capable and flexible one-time-use – they will give you usable pictures in more situations, but they remain cameras where choosing the right film and mastering composition are the two main factors of success.

It is surprising that you can buy a good single lens reflex for the same money as a single use camera or a compact autofocus. The market has its darlings – cameras like the Canon AE-1, the Canon EOS-3, the Nikon FM2, the Nikon F100 or the Minolta Maxxum 7 command relatively big bucks ($150.00 and above), but if you are patient and wait for an auction with no other bidder than you, you can still score real gems like the Canon EOS 620/650, the Pentax Program-A, the Minolta Maxxum 600SI, the Nikon FG, or the original FM, for little more than $9.99.

Avoid the antiques, the notoriously unreliable (the Pentax P3/P30, and most of the plastic-fantastic manual focus SLRs built after 1983), and the over-simplified cameras offering too little control to the photographer (Canon AV-1, Pentax MV, Nikon EM, and all the so-called “point and shoot autofocus SLRs” such as the Minolta Maxxum 3000i and its successors).

CamerAgx reviews: Canon EOS 620, Nikon FG, Pentax Program-A

My list of recommended SLRs includes manual focus as well as autofocus cameras – one can argue that autofocus cameras will deliver technically better pictures in the hands of beginners who have enough to do with the composition and with the control of the exposure parameters – I would simply avoid the autofocus SLRs of the first generation – their autofocus only operates on a narrow central area, and performs poorly on badly lit subjects, where it becomes loud, slow or inoperative. But anything made by one of the big three after 1992 should be fine (Nikon N90s, Minolta Maxxum 700SI, Canon EOS A2E..).

With SLRs, composition remains key (it’s what in the frame and how the image can be read that counts), but you have so many other parameters to play with – the precise determination of the focus point, of the depth of field, of the exposure, it gives you an unparalleled control over your images. Pick the right lens, play with the aperture to control the depth of field, with the shutter speed to freeze movement – you won’t be able to do any of this even with the most elaborate compact autofocus camera.


Featured image: Chalkfest, Marietta. Canon EOS 650. I paid less than $10.00 for the camera and its Canon 28-70 zoom.


Atlanta Centennial Park – Pentax Program-A; another $20.00 camera, lens included.
Portrait – Olympus OM-2 – playing with the depth of field
Sea Gull – Olympus OM-2. Still playing with the depth of field
Charleston – Nikon FM – playing with the shutter speed and a wide angle lens
Petra – the approach through the canyon. (Petra, Jordan – Kodak Ektar 100 – Nikon N2020 – Nikon Series E 35mm lens)

Kodak Ektar H35 and the quest for the cheapest usable film camera

A few weeks ago I entered a Five Below store and bought their finest reusable film camera, for $7.00. It works, but it’s not better than a disposable camera. And after burning one roll of film, my conclusion was that a beginner to film photography would be better off spending a few dollars more, somewhere between $35.00 and $50.00, either on a new fix focus point and shoot like the Kodak M35 or the Ilford Sprite, or on a used autofocus compact zoom manufactured in the nineteen nineties.

The Kodak Ektar H35 in its (optional) color coordinated case – the whole set looks much better than a disposable camera.

I was curious, and started hunting for bargains on the site of Shopgoowill.com.

I found a nice copy of a the Kodak Ektar H35, a reusable, fix focus camera, with its coordinated Grapsa case. The camera sells new for $50; add $15.00 for the case; here, second hand, the starting price of the auction was $9.99, and after a fierce bidding war (just kidding), the H35 became mine for $16.00. Adding handling, shipping and taxes, the H35 cost me just a tad under $30.00.

The Ektar H35 is not made by Eastman Kodak, the name is used under license by Reto, a Hong-Kong based company. The big differentiator, ironically for a product proudly wearing the name of Kodak, is that being a half frame camera, it will save you money on film and processing, by giving you twice as many images on a standard roll of 35mm film.

The shutter release button, and the ring surrounding the lens to turn the flash on. That’s it.

The high cost of film and of film processing makes shooting 24x17mm frames very tempting, financially – and since most images are destined to be shared on the small screen of smartphones, the loss of resolution (compared to a full frame 36x24mm negative) is not a real issue.

The H35 is styled like an old Kodak Instamatic, and is technically almost as simple as its remote ancestor – the fix focus 22mm lens opens at f/9.5 (22mm on a half frame gives you the angle of view of a 35mm lens on a full frame camera), and the shutter operates at 1/100 sec. The electronic flash is brought in service by turning a ring around the lens. That’s it. Compared to a disposable or to the original Instamatic, it has a better lens (2 elements, optical grade acrylic), and contrarily to its Kodak predecessor, it’s using standard 35mm film (the Instamatic’s negatives were 28x28mm, from a “126” film pack).

Two half frame cameras. The Pentax sells for 10 times the price of the Kodak. But there is a huge difference in Image Quality.

For the record, there is new version of this camera, the Ektar H35N, where the lens has been upgraded to include one glass element, and one aspherical acrylic element.

The Ektar is a recent and extremely simple camera – with not much to go wrong – and I was not taking a big risk buying it on Shopgoodwill.


Comparing the images out of the camera (as shot)

Somewhere in the North Highland neighborhood, Atlanta, GA – Kodak Ektar H35 Camera – Kentmere 400.

From the same vantage point, the same day, with another half-frame camera, the Pentax 17

Somewhere in the North Highland neighborhood, Atlanta, GA – Pentax 17 – Ilford Delta 400.

Shooting with the Ektar 35H

In its coordinated green case, the H35 looks very good. Much better than expected for such a cheap product. The film advance and the shutter release are smooth. But don’t look too close, though – it’s plastic, plastic, plastic. The film rewind crank is filmsy and looks really fragile – how long will it last? The viewfinder (oriented vertically – it’s a half frame camera) looks like the viewfinder of a full frame 35mm camera where two black strips would have been glued left and right: it’s narrow, uninspiring, and makes it difficult to predict exactly what will be in the frame.

Inman Park Neighborhood – Ford Pickup – Kodak Ektar H35, Kentmere 400, as shot

In all honesty, I really had to make a conscious effort to use the Ektar. It did not come naturally to me, and whatever other camera I had with me that day saw more use than the little Kodak. And if I had no other camera, I still preferred taking the picture with my phone. I never enjoyed using disposable cameras, and the truth is I did not enjoy using the H35 either.

Somewhere on the Atlanta Belt Line, Kodak Ektar H35, Kentmere 400 – as shot.

Image Quality

It took me months to finish a single roll of film, (48 frames on a 35mm roll sold for 24 “full frame” images, remember) and it stayed in my photo sling next to my “camera du jour” without seeing much use. But it gave me the opportunity to use it in parallel with a recent (and much more expensive) half frame camera, the Pentax 17, and with an older and generic point and shoot cameras of the turn of the century, the Argus M5600d.

The Pentax and the Argus are both larger, heavier, but much more interesting to use as cameras. But what about the image quality?

Looking at the B&W negatives shot with the Ektar, it’s obvious that there are huge differences in density from one image to another one – some are extremely dark, some are extremely clear, almost transparent – a consequence of the absence of any exposure control system in the camera. You have to rely on the exposure latitude of the film, on the image enhancing algorithms of the lab’s scanners, and on your ability to massage the picture in post-processing.


Comparing two half frame cameras:

Lake Clara Meer and midtown skyline – Atlanta – Kodak Ektar H35 – Kentmere 400, as shot

and shot the same day from the same vantage point, with the Pentax 17:

Lake Clara Meer and midtown skyline – Atlanta – Pentax 17 – Fujifilm Acros 2 100 ISO, as shot

The B&W negatives were not scanned in the true sense of the word, they were simply digitized with a Fujifilm X-T4 equipped with a Micro-Nikkor 55mm lens and the JJC Digitizing Adapter, then imported and inverted in Lightroom with only adjustments to the S curve. The images labelled “as shot” did not benefit for any other enhancement, and represent what the camera is really capable of, before any software filter or any artificial intelligence trickery is applied.

The images are a mixed bag – this Ektar is clearly a sunny-16 type of camera, and the best pictures are taken on a bright day, middle of the morning and middle of the afternoon. Don’t use it for landscapes – even urban landscapes – it seems optimized for subjects in the 4 to 30ft zone and anything beyond that is blurry.

On the other hand, some images – close-ups, street scenes, statues, are “interesting”, and pictures of houses and front yards are generally nice. Go figure.

Even at its preferred focusing distance, the resolution is surprisingly poor – it’s closer to an Holga than to any decent autofocus film camera like the Argus M5600 and its clones. As long as you look at them on the relatively small display of a smartphone, the images look fine. But they rapidly reach their limits, and on an iPad or a 15in laptop display they will look fuzzy, lacking definition and contrast.

On a final note, I tried to use the flash multiple times, and not a single one of the images was even remotely acceptable.


Another comparison – here the Ektar….

Avondale Estates, GA – Kodak Ektar H35 Camera – Kentmere 400, as shot

Here, the Argus M5600d

Avondale Estates – Argus M5600d – Kentmere 400 – minor adjustments in Lightroom.

Conclusion

If you’ve read this blog entry that far, you have understood that the H35 is not for me. It may be cute, but it’s still extremely basic, not really better than a single-use, throw away camera.

I was really disappointed by the image quality: displayed on a smartphone, some images can be somehow “acceptable” without ever being great – while some are not even salvageable, except maybe by AI – but what’s the point, then. And on anything larger than a smartphone display, they will generally fare poorly.

To the camera’s defense, I did not shoot with color film, and did not have the film processed and scanned on the Noritsu or Frontier machines of a pro lab – their software apply all sorts of enhancements to the images before saving them as Jpegs, and I’m sure their pictures would look better.

Jimmy Carter Presidential Library, Atlanta, GA – Kodak Ektar H35, Kentmere 400, as shot.

In other words, it’s not a camera that will give me the type of images I like. But it may work for photographers with different styles and tastes.

Photography is at the same a craft, and an art. If you don’t really care for the “craft side” of this activity, but have a keen eye, good image composition skills, and like your images on the rough side, a fix focus camera like the Ektar, or even a toy camera like a Holga or a Diana may be a good fit – you’ll have to learn how to exploit their limitations and their flaws to create images reflecting your unique vision.

Little Five Points, Atlanta – Kodak Ektar H35, Kentmere 400, as shot.

Was I fair in my evaluation of this camera, and is the Ektar H35 that bad?

I believe I was fair. The Ektar was in my photo bag when I was shooting with the Pentax 17 and the Argus, and although I clearly preferred having those two cameras in my hands, I still made a point of shooting one or two images per scene with the Ektar.

The cameras were not all loaded with the same film stock (I was using Fujifilm Acros and Ilford Delta 400 on the Pentax, Kentmere 400 on the Argus and the Ektar), but all three are good films, and the Kentmere gave me results that positively surprised me with the Argus.

The two rolls of Kentmere 400 (the Argus’ and the Ektar’s) were developed together, in the same tank, with Ilford’s Ilfosol 3 at standard dilution, so a botched film processing routine can not be pinned as a cause for the relatively poor quality of the pictures.

I had a peek at the images of the Ektar user group in Flickr. The pictures generally look better than mine, but the images I posted here are as shot, not enhanced by the software of the Noritsu or Frontier scanners used by the photo labs, or by an AI tool. For the sake of the argument, I submitted two of my images to ChatGPT, and after a few adjustments in Lightroom, I got the images shown below. Better, but are they still “my” images, or something else entirely?

Enhanced by ChatGPT for sharpness and contrast, then adjusted with a mask on the young lady to correct under-exposure in Lightroom.

Enhanced by Chatgpt for sharpness and contrast